Achilles Rupture: Surgery vs a Boot, Every Major Trial in One Table (2026)
A reference table of every randomized trial and major meta-analysis comparing Achilles rupture repair with a boot, plus minimally invasive vs open repair, each figure checked against the abstract and free to download.
By Dr. Efe Ozturk
· 12 min read
Medically reviewed by Dr. Efe Ozturk · Last reviewed

This reference page puts every randomized trial we found of Achilles rupture surgery vs non-surgical treatment, and the main pooled reviews, in one place. A randomized trial assigns treatment by chance, the fairest test we have. For a plain-language guide to the injury and recovery, read our Achilles tear guide: surgery or a boot, and how long recovery takes.
Key figures
- In a 2022 Norwegian trial of 526 adults, 6.2% of tendons treated without surgery tore again, against 0.6% after open repair and 0.6% after minimally invasive repair.[1]
- In a 2001 Swedish trial of 112 patients, 20.8% re-ruptured after eight weeks in plaster without surgery, against 1.7% after surgery with early brace rehab.[7]
- Across 29 studies (10 trials and 19 observational studies), 2.3% of Achilles ruptures re-ruptured after surgery and 3.9% without it, while other complications were 4.9% against 1.6%.[5]
- A 2025 review of 14 randomized trials (1,628 patients) found the re-rupture risk after surgery was less than a third of the risk without it (risk ratio 0.28 for minimally invasive and 0.30 for open repair).[8]
- In 9 trials that gave non-surgical patients early functional rehab and reported no significant difference (713 patients), the median re-rupture rate was 4.00% after open repair and 10.00% without surgery.[9]
- Across 33 studies of 35,896 patients, surgery raised the return-to-sport rate by 14.44% and lowered re-rupture by 3.52%.[4]
Achilles rupture surgery vs non-surgical: every randomized trial
| Study | Year | Country | Patients | Compared | Re-rupture, surgery | Re-rupture, no surgery | Other complications | Function result | Follow-up | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nistor | 1981 | Not stated | 105 | Surgery vs non-surgical care | 2 patients | 5 patients | 2 deep infections after surgery | Only minor differences | Not stated | [10] |
| Cetti | 1993 | Denmark | 111 | Surgery (56) vs non-surgical (55) | 3 of 56 (5.4%) | 7 of 55 (12.7%), plus 1 second re-rupture | 2 deep infections after surgery; fewer minor complications without | Surgery: more back to sport at the same level, less calf wasting, better motion | 1 year | [11] |
| Möller | 2001 | Sweden | 112 | Surgery with early brace rehab vs 8 weeks in plaster | 1.7% | 20.8% | Not reported in abstract | Equally good when complications were avoided | 2 years | [7] |
| Twaddle and Poon | 2007 | New Zealand | Not stated in abstract | Surgery vs no surgery, both with early motion in a removable brace | 1 patient needed re-repair | 1 patient needed re-repair | No difference | No difference in motion, calf size or MFAI score | 12 months | [12] |
| Metz | 2008 | Netherlands | 83 | Minimally invasive surgery vs functional brace, both full weight-bearing | 3 of 42 (7.1%) | 5 of 41 (12.2%) | Other complications 21% vs 36% (not significant) | Back to work at 59 vs 108 days with surgery | 1 year | [3] |
| Nilsson-Helander | 2010 | Sweden | 97 | Surgery vs no surgery, same early-motion rehab | 4% | 12% | Not reported in abstract | ATRS 88 vs 86 at 12 months; heel-rise work better after surgery | 1 year | [13] |
| Willits | 2010 | Canada | 144 | Surgery vs no surgery, both accelerated functional rehab | 2 of 72 (2.8%) | 3 of 72 (4.2%) | 13 vs 6 complications, mostly soft tissue after surgery | No clinically important difference | 2 years | [14] |
| Keating and Will | 2011 | UK | 80 | Open repair (39) vs cast (41) | 2 of 37 (5%) | 4 of 39 (10%) | Not reported in abstract | Better SMFA score with surgery at 3 months; similar at 1 year | 1 year | [15] |
| Maempel (long-term follow-up of Keating and Will) | 2020 | UK (same trial) | 64 of the 80 | Same trial | 2 patients | 4 patients | Not reported in abstract | No difference in ATRS (94 vs 95) or SMFA | Mean 15.7 years | [16] |
| Olsson | 2013 | Sweden | 100 | Stable repair with accelerated rehab vs no surgery | None of 49 | 5 patients | 6 superficial infections after surgery; no major soft-tissue problems | No difference in symptoms or activity; jump and hop tests better after surgery | 12 months | [17] |
| Lantto | 2016 | Finland | 60 | Open repair vs no surgery, same accelerated rehab | Not reported in abstract | Not reported in abstract | Not reported in abstract | Similar score (79.5 vs 75.7); calf 10% to 18% stronger after surgery | 18 months | [2] |
| Manent | 2019 | Spain | 34 | No surgery (11) vs percutaneous (11) vs open (12), early weight-bearing | None | None | Not reported in abstract | Success in 9 of 11 percutaneous, 10 of 12 open, 11 of 11 non-surgical | 1 year | [18] |
| Myhrvold | 2022 | Norway | 526 analyzed (554 randomized) | No surgery vs open repair vs minimally invasive repair | 0.6% open; 0.6% minimally invasive | 6.2% | Nerve injury 2.8% open, 5.2% minimally invasive, 0.6% without surgery | No difference in ATRS change at 12 months | 12 months | [1] |
ATRS is the Achilles tendon Total Rupture Score, a 0 to 100 symptom and activity score. SMFA and MFAI are general function questionnaires. “Not reported in abstract” means the published abstract does not give the figure.
What do the meta-analyses say about the Achilles tendon re-rupture rate?
A meta-analysis pools many studies. These reviews share many of the same trials, so read them as repeated looks at one body of evidence.
| Review | Year | Included | Re-rupture, surgery | Re-rupture, no surgery | Other complications | Function and return | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wilkins and Bisson | 2012 | 7 trials, 677 patients (open repair) | 3.6% | 8.8% | More deep infections, scar complaints and sural nerve numbness after surgery | Strength could not be pooled | [19] |
| Soroceanu | 2012 | 10 trials | Rates not given: 8.8 points lower with surgery where early motion was not used; no significant difference (1.7 points) with early motion | Rates not given | 15.8 points more after surgery | Back to work 19.16 days sooner after surgery; no difference in strength or function | [20] |
| Ochen (BMJ) | 2019 | 10 trials (944 patients) and 19 observational studies (14,918) | 2.3% | 3.9% | 4.9% vs 1.6%, mainly infection (2.8% after surgery) | No significant re-rupture difference with accelerated early-motion rehab | [5] |
| Reda | 2020 | 9 studies, 822 patients | Risk ratio 0.36 | Rate not given | More wound complications after surgery | No difference in function scores or motion | [21] |
| Deng | 2023 | 13 trials, 1,465 patients | Risk ratio 0.27 open; 0.14 minimally invasive | Rate not given | Not reported in abstract | Not reported in abstract | [22] |
| Bragg | 2024 | 9 trials with early functional rehab, 713 patients | Median 4.00% (open repair) | Median 10.00% | Not reported in abstract | A median of 3 changed outcomes would make the trials’ “no difference” results significant | [9] |
| Fan | 2024 | 14 trials, 1,399 patients | Odds ratio 0.30 | Rate not given | Odds ratio 3.28 for other complications | Less sick leave and fewer abnormal calves after surgery; no difference in return to sport or ATRS | [23] |
| Yang | 2025 | 33 studies, 35,896 patients | Risk ratio 0.44 (3.52% lower) | Rate not given | More infection (risk ratio 2.54) and nerve injury (3.67) after surgery | Return to sport 14.44% higher after surgery; no difference in ATRS | [4] |
| Xu | 2025 | 14 trials, 1,628 patients | Risk ratio 0.28 minimally invasive; 0.30 open | Rate not given | More complications after open repair (risk ratio 3.03); no significant difference after minimally invasive repair | No difference in function; earlier return to work after minimally invasive repair | [8] |
A risk ratio below 1 means fewer re-ruptures after surgery: 0.30 means about 30% of the risk without surgery.
Is minimally invasive Achilles repair as strong as open repair?
Minimally invasive (small-incision or percutaneous, through the skin) repair stitches the tendon through short cuts instead of one long opening.
| Study | Year | Design | Patients | Re-rupture, minimally invasive | Re-rupture, open | Nerve injury | Wound and infection | Function | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Grassi | 2018 | 8 trials | 358 (182 vs 176) | No difference | No difference | No difference | Fewer overall complications (risk ratio 0.21) and wound infections (0.15) with small incisions | More good or excellent results with small incisions; same return to preinjury activity | [24] |
| Myhrvold | 2022 | Trial, Norway | Part of 526 | 0.6% | 0.6% | 5.2% vs 2.8% | Not reported in abstract | No difference in ATRS change | [1] |
| Attia | 2023 | 10 trials | 522 | 1.5% | 2.5% | Sural nerve 3.4% vs none | Superficial infection 0.4% vs 6.0%; operation 29.7 vs 51.0 minutes | AOFAS 95.7 vs 94.8 (no difference) | [6] |
| Deng | 2023 | 13 trials (network) | 1,465 | No difference (open vs minimally invasive risk ratio 0.72) | No difference | Not reported in abstract | Not reported in abstract | Not reported in abstract | [22] |
What the numbers mean for you
If you want to sprint, jump or push off hard again, repair most reliably keeps the tendon in one piece. The clearest difference across these trials is fewer second tears, and some also found a stronger calf and an earlier return to work or sport. Small-incision repair kept those gains with fewer wound infections.
A boot with early motion and weight-bearing is a reasonable path for some people. With that kind of program, the gap in re-ruptures narrows.[20,5] Decide with a Foot and Ankle Surgeon soon after the injury, because repair works best when it is done early: a torn tendon shortens and scars over time, and a late repair may need donor tissue.[25]
Dr. Efe Ozturk, a double board certified Foot and Ankle Surgeon and podiatrist, sees Achilles ruptures in weekend athletes and competitive players. Learn about our Achilles tendon care, sports medicine and foot and ankle surgery, or read whether Achilles tendonitis can lead to a rupture. Our sister practice explains Achilles rupture: surgery or not (external site) in more detail. We see patients in Lyndhurst, Paramus and Millburn; find an office on our locations page. Please call our office at 908-215-5953 to inquire about your insurance.
How we built this table
We searched PubMed on November 22, 2026, for randomized trials comparing operative with non-operative treatment of acute Achilles tendon rupture in adults, for systematic reviews and meta-analyses of that question, and for trials and reviews comparing minimally invasive with open repair. We kept trials of any year, because older trials shaped today’s practice, and English-language abstracts only. We left out trials of rehab protocols or a treatment-selection algorithm alone, cohort studies, and reviews of reviews. Every figure was checked against the PubMed abstract. Where an abstract gave only counts (Cetti, Metz and Willits), the percentage in parentheses is our own arithmetic from those counts. Last reviewed November 2026. We update this page as new trials are published.
The limits. Most trials were small, and in many of them the difference in re-ruptures was not statistically significant on its own. When non-surgical patients moved early, the re-rupture gap shrank and was no longer significant in two reviews,[20,5] and the largest trial found no difference in symptom scores at 12 months.[1] Surgery carries more infections, wound problems and nerve injuries, and small-incision repair had more sural nerve injuries than open repair.[5,4,6] Follow-up ranged from one year to 15.7 years, rehab varied, and we read abstracts, not full papers. Nothing here is personal medical advice.
Common questions
Is Achilles rupture surgery better than non-surgical treatment?
For keeping the tendon from tearing again, yes: repair cut the re-rupture risk to less than a third in a 2025 review of 14 trials.[8] Function scores at a year were similar in the largest trial,[1] so your sport, health and goals guide the choice.
What is the Achilles tendon re-rupture rate?
It depends on the treatment and the rehab. Pooled across 29 studies it was 2.3% after surgery and 3.9% without.[5] Without surgery, it was 6.2% in the largest modern trial[1] and 20.8% after eight weeks in plaster in a 2001 trial.[7]
Achilles tear vs rupture: is there a difference?
No. Both words describe the same injury, which can be partial or complete.[25]
Does minimally invasive repair work as well as open repair?
In 10 trials, re-ruptures and function scores were similar, with fewer superficial infections and shorter operations after small-incision repair but more temporary sural nerve problems.[6]
Download the data
Every row in the three tables above, with PubMed ids and DOIs, is in one file: Download the table as a CSV file (external site).
How to cite this page
Ozturk E. Achilles Rupture: Surgery vs a Boot, Every Major Trial in One Table (2026). Ozturk Foot & Ankle. Published November 22, 2026. Updated November 22, 2026. https://www.ozturkfootankle.com/blog/achilles-rupture-surgery-vs-nonsurgical-trials (external site)
Reviewed by Dr. Efe Ozturk, Foot and Ankle Surgeon.

About the author
Dr. Efe Ozturk
Foot and Ankle Surgeon. Dr. Ozturk is double board certified, as a Diplomate of the American Board of Podiatric Medicine (DABPM) and a Fellow of the Academy of Physicians in Wound Healing (FAPWH), and is a Fellow of the American Society of Podiatric Surgeons (FASPS) and the American Society of Podiatric Medicine (FASPM). Trained in forefoot and rearfoot reconstructive surgery at Morristown Medical Center; sees patients in Lyndhurst, Paramus and Millburn.
Where to be seen
Dr. Ozturk sees patients at each of these offices, and one phone number reaches all of them.
References
- 1.Myhrvold SB, Brouwer EF, Andresen TKM, et al. Nonoperative or Surgical Treatment of Acute Achilles' Tendon Rupture. N Engl J Med. 2022;386(15):1409-1420. PubMed 35417636 (external site)
- 2.Lantto I, Heikkinen J, Flinkkila T, et al. A Prospective Randomized Trial Comparing Surgical and Nonsurgical Treatments of Acute Achilles Tendon Ruptures. Am J Sports Med. 2016;44(9):2406-14. PubMed 27307495 (external site)
- 3.Metz R, Verleisdonk EJ, van der Heijden GJ, et al. Acute Achilles tendon rupture: minimally invasive surgery versus nonoperative treatment with immediate full weightbearing--a randomized controlled trial. Am J Sports Med. 2008;36(9):1688-94. PubMed 18645042 (external site)
- 4.Yang Z, Ge Z, Zheng J, Zhang L, Yang Z. Surgical treatment versus conservative management for acute Achilles tendon rupture: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Orthop Surg Res. 2025;20(1):626. PubMed 40629410 (external site)
- 5.Ochen Y, Beks RB, van Heijl M, et al. Operative treatment versus nonoperative treatment of Achilles tendon ruptures: systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ. 2019;364:k5120. PubMed 30617123 (external site)
- 6.Attia AK, Mahmoud K, d’Hooghe P, Bariteau J, Labib SA, Myerson MS. Outcomes and Complications of Open Versus Minimally Invasive Repair of Acute Achilles Tendon Ruptures: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials. Am J Sports Med. 2023;51(3):825-836. PubMed 34908499 (external site)
- 7.Möller M, Movin T, Granhed H, Lind K, Faxén E, Karlsson J. Acute rupture of tendon Achillis. A prospective randomised study of comparison between surgical and non-surgical treatment. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 2001;83(6):843-8. PubMed 11521926 (external site)
- 8.Xu S, Xiao J, Li Y, Liu E, Qin Y, Shen X. Operative versus nonoperative management of acute Achilles tendon rupture: a systematic review and meta-analysis of clinical outcomes from randomized controlled trials. Ann Med. 2025;57(1):2537349. PubMed 41243574 (external site)
- 9.Bragg JT, Ruelos VCB, McIntyre JA, et al. Reverse Fragility Index Comparing Rates of Rerupture After Open Achilles Tendon Repair Versus Early Functional Rehabilitation: A Systematic Review of Randomized Controlled Trials. Am J Sports Med. 2024;52(4):1116-1121. PubMed 37306060 (external site)
- 10.Nistor L. Surgical and non-surgical treatment of Achilles Tendon rupture. A prospective randomized study. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1981;63(3):394-9. PubMed 7204438 (external site)
- 11.Cetti R, Christensen SE, Ejsted R, Jensen NM, Jorgensen U. Operative versus nonoperative treatment of Achilles tendon rupture. A prospective randomized study and review of the literature. Am J Sports Med. 1993;21(6):791-9. PubMed 8291628 (external site)
- 12.Twaddle BC, Poon P. Early motion for Achilles tendon ruptures: is surgery important? A randomized, prospective study. Am J Sports Med. 2007;35(12):2033-8. PubMed 17885221 (external site)
- 13.Nilsson-Helander K, Silbernagel KG, Thomeé R, et al. Acute achilles tendon rupture: a randomized, controlled study comparing surgical and nonsurgical treatments using validated outcome measures. Am J Sports Med. 2010;38(11):2186-93. PubMed 20802094 (external site)
- 14.Willits K, Amendola A, Bryant D, et al. Operative versus nonoperative treatment of acute Achilles tendon ruptures: a multicenter randomized trial using accelerated functional rehabilitation. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2010;92(17):2767-75. PubMed 21037028 (external site)
- 15.Keating JF, Will EM. Operative versus non-operative treatment of acute rupture of tendo Achillis: a prospective randomised evaluation of functional outcome. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 2011;93(8):1071-8. PubMed 21768631 (external site)
- 16.Maempel JF, Clement ND, Wickramasinghe NR, Duckworth AD, Keating JF. Operative repair of acute Achilles tendon rupture does not give superior patient-reported outcomes to nonoperative management. Bone Joint J. 2020;102-B(7):933-940. PubMed 32600149 (external site)
- 17.Olsson N, Silbernagel KG, Eriksson BI, et al. Stable surgical repair with accelerated rehabilitation versus nonsurgical treatment for acute Achilles tendon ruptures: a randomized controlled study. Am J Sports Med. 2013;41(12):2867-76. PubMed 24013347 (external site)
- 18.Manent A, López L, Corominas H, et al. Acute Achilles Tendon Ruptures: Efficacy of Conservative and Surgical (Percutaneous, Open) Treatment-A Randomized, Controlled, Clinical Trial. J Foot Ankle Surg. 2019;58(6):1229-1234. PubMed 31679677 (external site)
- 19.Wilkins R, Bisson LJ. Operative versus nonoperative management of acute Achilles tendon ruptures: a quantitative systematic review of randomized controlled trials. Am J Sports Med. 2012;40(9):2154-60. PubMed 22802271 (external site)
- 20.Soroceanu A, Sidhwa F, Aarabi S, Kaufman A, Glazebrook M. Surgical versus nonsurgical treatment of acute Achilles tendon rupture: a meta-analysis of randomized trials. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2012;94(23):2136-43. PubMed 23224384 (external site)
- 21.Reda Y, Farouk A, Abdelmonem I, El Shazly OA. Surgical versus non-surgical treatment for acute Achilles' tendon rupture. A systematic review of literature and meta-analysis. Foot Ankle Surg. 2020;26(3):280-288. PubMed 31027878 (external site)
- 22.Deng H, Cheng X, Yang Y, et al. Rerupture outcome of conservative versus open repair versus minimally invasive repair of acute Achilles tendon ruptures: A systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS One. 2023;18(5):e0285046. PubMed 37130120 (external site)
- 23.Fan L, Hu Y, Zhou L, Fu W. Surgical vs. nonoperative treatment for acute Achilles' tendon rupture: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Front Surg. 2024;11:1483584. PubMed 39640199 (external site)
- 24.Grassi A, Amendola A, Samuelsson K, et al. Minimally Invasive Versus Open Repair for Acute Achilles Tendon Rupture: Meta-Analysis Showing Reduced Complications, with Similar Outcomes, After Minimally Invasive Surgery. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2018;100(22):1969-1981. PubMed 30480601 (external site)
- 25.American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. Achilles Tendon Rupture (Tear). OrthoInfo. orthoinfo.org (external site)
This is general health information and isn’t a substitute for advice from a clinician who knows your history. Read our medical disclaimer and how we write and review content.
More from the blog
Sports & running
Return to Sport After Foot and Ankle Injuries: Published Rates and Times (2026 Table)
A reference table of published return-to-sport rates and times after Jones fracture, Lisfranc, navicular, ankle fracture, syndesmosis, ankle ligament, talus cartilage, Achilles and turf toe treatment, surgical and non-surgical, each figure checked against the abstract and free to download.
Sports & running
Foot and Ankle Injury Tracker 2026-27: NFL, NBA, NHL and Soccer
Our foot and ankle injury tracker: 67 notable ankle, Achilles, foot and toe injuries across the NFL, NBA, NHL and Europe’s big soccer clubs as of November 22, 2026, each with a dated source. Surgery was reported for 19 of them.
Sports & running
Biggest sports injuries this week: Harry Kane’s ankle surgery, Puka Nacua, Asa Newell and more across the NFL, NBA, NHL, MLB and soccer
The new board: the biggest sports injuries across the NFL, NBA, NHL, MLB and five soccer leagues as of November 22, 2026, led by Harry Kane’s ankle surgery. Nine of the 21 athletes have had surgery on the injured area, and each league has a lesson for everyday athletes.